Justices could rule out business liability under 1789 lawOctober 11, 2017 5:43pm

WASHINGTON (AP) — The Supreme Court appears ready to rule out lawsuits in U.S. courts against businesses by foreign victims of human rights abuses and extremist attacks.

A case argued Wednesday pitted Israeli victims of attacks in Israel, the West Bank and Gaza in the 1990s and 2000s against Jordan-based Arab Bank. The victims claim that the bank helped finance the attacks.

The issue is whether the foreigners can use an 18th-century law to hold the bank accountable for its role.

The court already has limited the ability of foreign victims to sue under the 1789 Alien Tort Statute.

It appeared from the argument that the five conservative justices could find that corporations cannot be sued at all under that law. Such an outcome would be another blow to a more than 30-year-old strategy by human rights lawyers to use civil suits to pursue individuals who may be responsible for torture and other atrocities, as well as companies with operations in countries with poor records in the area of human rights.

"My understanding is that this sort of relief is fairly unique," Chief Justice John Roberts said of the efforts to hold businesses liable under the law. Roberts did not seem to be persuaded by lawyer Jeffrey Fisher's efforts to persuade him otherwise.

Justice Anthony Kennedy said little during the argument, but he did suggest that allowing corporations to be sued under the law might be unfair.

Questions from the liberal justices indicated they would vote for allowing the lawsuit against the bank to proceed.

Referring to an international treaty prohibiting the financing of terrorism, Justice Stephen Breyer said, "If it doesn't apply to corporations, who does it apply to?"

Paul Clement, representing the bank, told the court that suits against corporate officers and high-ranking officials might be possible, but not against the corporation itself.

The case came to the high court after the 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in New York ruled that the bank was immune from such lawsuits. Other federal appeals courts have found that corporations can be sued for damages under the Alien Tort Statute.

Victims in the case allege that the bank, through the involvement of its New York branch, knowingly distributed millions of dollars to finance suicide bombings and make "martyrdom" payments to reward the families of militants who killed civilians.

The bank denies the allegations and argues that allowing the victims' claims to go forward would interfere with U.S. foreign policy and lead to diplomatic friction.

The Alien Tort Statute, adopted in part to deal with piracy claims, went unused for most of American history until rights lawyers dusted it off beginning in the late 1970s. The Supreme Court cautiously endorsed the use of the law in 2004, but left unanswered precisely who could be held liable and in what circumstances.

In 2013, the justices ruled that people or entities sued under the Alien Tort Statute must have a real connection to the United States. The court declined then to decide whether businesses could be sued.

Fisher said the 2013 ruling had eliminated nearly 30 of the 40 cases pending in U.S. courts.

Indeed, even if the victims win in the Supreme Court, they might ultimately lose their suit.

The Trump administration is urging the high court to return the case to the appeals court in New York with instructions to decide whether there are sufficient connections to the United States to allow the suit to go forward.

Page 1 of 1

More Stories Like This

Hawaii Attorney General Douglas Chin speaks to the Associated Press about Hawaii's lawsuit challenging President Donald Trump's travel ban, Tuesday, Oct. 17, 2017, in Honolulu. A federal judge in Hawaii blocked most of President Donald Trump's latest travel ban Tuesday, just hours before it was set to take effect, saying the revised order "suffers from precisely the same maladies as its predecessor." It was the third set of travel restrictions issued by the president to be thwarted, in whole or in part, by the courts. (AP Photo/Caleb Jones)
Q-and-A: A look at most recent travel ban rulings
FILE- In this Jan. 19, 2016, file photo, Sons of Confederate Veterans and other groups parade on the grounds of the state Capitol in Jackson, Miss., in support of keeping the Confederate battle emblem on the state flag. Attorneys for the Mississippi governor say two levels of federal courts have been correct in blocking a lawsuit that challenges the Confederate battle emblem on the state flag. Representing Republican Gov. Phil Bryant, assistant state attorneys general filed papers Wednesday, Oct. 18, 2017, with the U.S. Supreme Court. They said Carlos Moore, an African-American attorney from Mississippi who sued the state, has failed to show he suffered harm because of the flag. (AP Photo/Rogelio V. Solis, File)
Lawyers: Courts correctly rejected Confederate flag lawsuit
Lawsuit seeks disclosure of FBI 9/11 investigation filesA lawsuit seeking disclosure of FBI files on a reported U.S.-based support network for the 9/11 hijackers has reached a federal appeals court. A Florida online publication wants to go to trial to force the FBI to comply with the Freedom of Information Act
Judge orders government to allow abortion for immigrant teenA federal judge has ordered the government to allow a pregnant 17-year old immigrant, who was detained after entering the country illegally, to undergo an abortion
FILE - In this July 2, 2015, file photo, Russian metals magnate Oleg Deripaska attends Independence Day celebrations at Spaso House, the residence of the American Ambassador, in Moscow, Russia. A federal judge has dismissed a defamation lawsuit brought against The Associated Press by Russian billionaire Deripaska, who has ties to Russian President Vladimir Putin. (AP Photo/Alexander Zemlianichenko, File)
Judge dismisses Russian billionaire's suit against AP
President Donald Trump looks down at his podium during a news conference with Greek Prime Minister Alexis Tsipras in the Rose Garden of the White House in Washington, Tuesday, Oct. 17, 2017. (AP Photo/Pablo Martinez Monsivais)
Trump's lawyers to ask judge to toss emoluments lawsuit
This component is currently unavailable.
AdChoices

Related Searches

Related Searches

AdChoices